The Reshoots Scale
I approach reviews differently from most sites. Instead of star ratings or percentages, I use my Reshoots Scoring System, inspired by the filmmaking process:
“No Reshoots Required” → The highest praise. Everything works — the script, the performances, the visuals, the pacing. It’s the kind of experience I wouldn’t change at all.
“Minor Reshoots Required” → Very good overall, but there are small tweaks that could make it better. Maybe a scene runs too long, a subplot needs tightening, or a character arc could be refined.
“Major Reshoots Required” → The foundations might be solid, but significant changes are needed. Whether it’s pacing issues, uneven storytelling, or missed opportunities, the story would benefit from major revisions.
I chose this system because it’s fun, different, and honest. More importantly, it reflects how I think about storytelling: even great films and shows can often be improved, and breaking down what works — and what doesn’t — is what I enjoy most.